A year later a call went into the Gallup Police Department with a young girl claiming to be Anthonette and in Albuquerque, New Mexico. Then in the background as she was going to say her where abouts a voice said "Who said you can use the phone". Then the call ended.
Then five years later in Carson City, Nevada a waitress claims to have seen Anthonette in a restaurant with a male and a female. Apparently the girl who she thought was Anthonette wrote on a napkin " Please Help Me, Call the Police".
* The night of Anthonette's disappearance her mother was at a local bar and left her and her sisters with a babysitter.
* Anthonette;s mother often left Anthonette and her sisters alone when she went and frequented bars.
* There is rumors that Penny Cayedito was a drug addict.
Anthonette Christine Cayedito: (December 15th,1976) Last seen April 6th 1986. Was a 9 year old Navajo Native American/ Italian girl who went missing in Gallup, New Mexico in 1986. Mother Penny Cayedito (1952-1999) Father Anthony Montoya (1951-2012).
|What Anthonette might look like at age 35|